My rationale

Today I made a difficult decision.

When I started working at Friends of the Earth Scotland it really opened my eyes to the injustices caused by the use and abuse of environmental resources. I knew the planet and our ecology was struggling because of humanity and our over-consumption, but I got to meet people whose families and communities had been destroyed by companies like Shell and Coca-Cola over-extracting the local resources.

So I put my heart and soul into the job, and it almost killed me. Partly for reasons outlined elsewhere in this blog, and partly for other reasons, which will remain unspoken.

But, alongside other colleagues, I was touched and inspired by my international colleagues. They were kidnapped, tortured, driven off their land. They started Occupy type camps to protest environmental destruction. They mobilised thousands of people with only volunteer resources. They travelled under threat of not being allowed re-entry to their country. Nothing I faced was even a midge on the skin of what they faced.

But I knew my wee group in Scotland inspired others. We were feisty and kept environmental justice at the heart of our work. We never forgot, despite funding problems, that we were representing an international network whose work could easily be undermined by the smallest decision we made.

And when I had to leave I was ridiculously sad. And even last week I was telling my partner how I had given up my ideal job.

So today when I stopped my direct debit to Friends of the Earth Scotland and transferred that donation to Friends of the Earth International I did so because I think my local branch have let me down.

And I, perhaps more than anyone, know how difficult it is to be FoES in the current environment. But I cannot stand by the Director’s decision to come out in support of Yes Scotland a year before the referendum.

I’m not saying I disagree with the premise that the environment will be better served in an independent Scotland, but I want my money to support an organisation who will fight for environmental justice regardless of the result of the vote in September 2014. And by coming out for one side, the Director risks his, and his organisation’s influence.

I’m sure he weighed his decision, and I’m not him, so can’t pre-judge his decision. But it doesn’t sit well with me. So I have withdrawn my financial support for Friends of the Earth Scotland, and instead directed it towards the international network.

I’m sorry guys, I really am, but this is the final straw for me. Neutrality as we go forward to September 18th 2014 is vital.

I wish you well, and I know it’s been hard to even survive since 2011, but you should’ve warned me about this. This is one step beyond.

4 thoughts on “My rationale

  1. Shame you confuse my personal position with that of the organisation, which is still entirely neutral. I think every person in Scotland should have the right to say what they think on the big issues of the day, whoever they work for and without their employer being punished for it.

    • I understand that Richard, but as someone who works within Scottish politics, and as the head of a Scottish charity I would expect you to keep your opinion to yourself.
      In my opinion it harms the charity you represent for you to make this statement. But it’s your decision to make, and so be it.
      I have transferred my financial support. Others may choose not to, or indeed think your view makes the charity you represent worthy of increased support. This is just my opinion.

      • Hang on, on a blog where you voice your personal political opinions, you are telling another member of the same organisation that they are wrong to exercise this same right? That is more than a little bit hypocritical.

      • Thanks for stopping by Simon. My problem is that this persons views were publicised widely because of his position, not because of his views, and that could damage his organisation. Just my opinion though. But think a seldom read blog is hardly equivalent to a press release from Yes Scotland…

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s